Academic Editing

 

Academic editing is highly specialized, no matter the topic. Whether you are writing a paper for a class, a thesis or dissertation, a journal article, or a conference presentation, you have to take into account many aspects that don't always exist in other sectors.

 

Argumentation

Evidence

Lit Review

Ethical Data Analysis

Logical organization and flow

Consistency

Summary and paraphrasing

Effective and engaging language

Tone and voice

Stylebooks or in-house stylesheets

Formatting to specifications

Citations and References

Language issues specific to ESL/ELL

And, of course, grammar, spelling, punctuation, diction, and syntax

 

Editing an academic paper, thesis, dissertation, or book is a specialized skill and a different process than editing a novel or technical document. It requires an eye for the conventions of the discipline, academia in general, and the tenets of good research, argument, and analysis. As such, editing has specific ramifications to academics, whether a student trying for a grade or defending to a committee, or a professor publishing in journals or with a university press. Further, the higher the level of education, the more skill a scholar or researcher is expected to apply in their writing, whether or not English is their discipline (or, indeed, their first language).

 

Before starting the editorial process, it is important to identify the state and stage of the of the document and clarify your editorial requirements. If you are preparing your manuscript for submission, global suggestions about argument and cohesion are probably unwelcome. Conversely, if you are concerned about larger issues of logic or the weight of your research, an editor reviewing citations and format will frustrate you.

 

Editing is an iterative, communicative process, especially when a lot is riding on your work—grades, degrees, tenure—and final approval of every change is always the responsibility of the author. It is imperative for the writer to be aware that no editor can (or should) "fix everything," nor is it appropriate to address all problems in one round of review. No editor should ever guarantee 100% accuracy; most reputable contractors will provide 98% accuracy at proofreading stage.

 

It is suggested that academics utilize peers in their field for substantive review and/or editing at the first—possibly second—stage of the editorial process. This allows a review of content by others with similar knowledge. However, it should be noted that most editors can identify a weak argument, no matter what the topic. Proofreading for submission should be done by a different professional with specialized knowledge of the English language, but not necessarily a specific discipline, especially for ESL/ELL students.

 

Substantive editing ($0.04-0.05/word)

 

SUBSTANTIVE EDITING WILL NOT BE UNDERTAKEN FOR CURRENT STUDENTS WITHOUT PERMISSION FROM THEIR PROFESSOR OR COMMITTEE.

 

— Global suggestions for strengthening argument, concision, audience analysis, citation use, readability, etc.

— Section-, paragraph-, and sentence-level suggestions for improvement

— Questions of continuity, consistency, and coherence

— Identification of grammatical patterns of error, but not necessarily word-level correction.

— This is not the stage to be concerned with perfect grammatical accuracy, as larger changes will require additional review.

 

Line (copy) editing ($0.03-0.04/word)

— Sentence and word-level corrections of grammatical and spelling errors

— Identification of egregious errors of continuity, argument, consistency, and coherence

— Review and formatting of citations

— Plagiarism check, as needed

— 80-90% grammatical accuracy is expected.

 

Proofreading ($0.015-0.03/word)

— Just prior to manuscript formatting for submission or publication.

— Word- and character-level grammatical and spelling, based on either standard conventions or any given style book.

— Review of word/page count requirements

— No identification of errors in continuity, consistency, and coherence

— The least iterative stage, as at this point, the editor's role is objective, not subjective.

— 95-98% accuracy is expected. (No professional editor should guarantee 100% accuracy.)

— Not suggested until you are ready for submission, as changes require additional review.

 

Ancillary Writing/Review (rate varies)

— Abstracts

— Keywords

— Outlines

— Query letters

— Academic biographies

— Academic CVs and resumes

 

Notes on Writing and Editing Rates

— Variations in price depend on an initial review of materials, which is undertaken at no charge prior to the author contracting editorial services.

— All editing will be completed in Microsoft Word, using Track Changes. Other software, such as Acrobat, OpenOffice, or InDesign, or provision of handwritten notes will incur additional costs.

— Per-word rates above are based on a US-standard 8.5x11-inch page, single-sided, 12-point Times New Roman font, double-spaced, 1-inch margins on all sides, 1/2-inch paragraph indent, no space between paragraphs. (This results in about 275 words per page.)

— Footnotes, captions, and  graphics with words are included in the word count. Visuals, numerical tables/charts/graphs, equations, etc. are not (and will not be checked for accuracy).

— The rate is based on submitted, not corrected, manuscript.

— Flat rates, discounts, and payment plans are available when contracting for multiple services, or for long-term projects.

 

Formatting and Graphics

Academic Formatting (varies by length; $25 - 100)

— Microsoft Word file for journal or publisher submission

— PDF

— This service assumes provision of specific formatting requirements.

 

States in Disguise:

Causes of State Support for Rebel Groups

 

by Belgin San-Akca

Assistant Professor,

Dept. of International Relations,

Koç University, Istanbul

 

Published by:

Oxford University Press,

2016

 

The first book-length study of external support in internal conflict Identifies and explains the domestic and international factors that trigger external state

support for rebel groups.

TESTIMONIALS

"Mari's turnaround was amazing: I had my 5000-word article back within the day, and her editing was thorough and incisive. Her suggestions vastly improved the final product, helping slim it down in word count and bring out the argument more clearly. I would absolutely recommend Ms Christie's editing services to any academic seeking honest feedback and intelligent improvements."

 

Dr. Jacqueline Reiter, historian and author of

 

 

The Late Lord: The Life of John Pitt - 2nd Earl of Chatham

"Mari has been great to work with, and without her tireless help and patience I would not have had nearly as many publications on my academic CV. She is a true professional who is pleasure to work with. Her recommendations and grammar corrections have enabled me to publish a lot more (with quality) than I would otherwise would have."

 

Richard Miller

Associate Professor,

Kobe Gakuin University

All Content © Mari Anne Christie